Getting obsessive with Josh Smith's game-winning dunk

Leave a comment

Last night, Josh Smith won the internet with a game-winning tip dunk as time expired. This everyone agrees on. What isn’t as clear is which Magic player screwed up to give Smith a clear run to the rim for the game-winner. The general consensus is that Rashard Lewis, the Magic player closest to Smith, messed up by failing to box him out. 

However, there have been some dissenting opinions. In response to David Thorpe’s opinion on TrueHoop, Stephen Danley noted that Lewis and Jameer Nelson were responsible for boxing out three guys on the weak side because Dwight Howard had rotated over to play help-side defense. This fellow directly blames Howard for the mistake, and he uses tables to illustrate it. On NBA Playbook, one of Sebastian Pruiti’s stills of the play makes it look pretty clear that Rashard should have found Josh Smith and boxed him out. 
After looking at the video many, many times, here are some of my conclusions:
-First of all, this was a bit of a freak occurrence. Not only does the ball carom off the rim perfectly for Smith’s dunk, but almost nobody else in the league is capable of making that play. When the shot went up with 1.9 seconds to play, Lewis is standing with his toes on the charge circle as Smith stands at the three-point line. When it hits the rim with 1.3 seconds away, Smith is still a good two to three steps outside of the paint. A second later, game over. Of the thousands of times Rashard Lewis has boxed a man out in his life, he’s probably faced very few opponents capable of swooping in that quickly for a tip dunk after starting at the three-point line. Yes, Smith already has one tip-dunk game winner this season, but Lewis had about a half a second to remember this and override his instinct, which is that there was no chance Smith was going to be able to get to that rebound. Like the victims of a LeBron James chase-down block, Lewis got burned by letting instinct take over and forgetting the athletic capabilities of the player behind him. 
-Second, when the shot goes up, Lewis and Nelson aren’t actually responsible for three men, because Marvin Williams is hanging out beyond the three-point line and never comes inside of it. In this case, Jameer’s responsibility should have been to box out Mario West while Lewis makes sure he puts a body on Smith. Nelson is the smallest man on the floor anyways, and doesn’t quite get over to box out West, who is on the charge circle when the ball hits the rim. Lewis moves ever so slightly to his left towards West, giving Smith the window he needs to blow by Lewis’ right shoulder and dunk it through. 
Ultimately, my final opinion is that there’s no one mistake that made this possible for the Hawks. Howard ended up roaming a little too far over. Nelson didn’t box out his man as well as he could have. Lewis didn’t make it a priority to know where the best athlete on the Hawks was when the ball went up. The ball bounced perfectly to one of the few guys capable of making the game-winning play. It’s one of those things that will happen over the course of an 82-game season. Unfortunately for the Magic, it happened to them this time. 

Kings’ Karl admits mistakes in DeMarcus Cousins trade controversey

Leave a comment

In the NBA, elite players have the leverage. It is just simple supply and demand.

DeMarcus Cousins is an elite player — and a favorite of owner Vivek Ranadive. He is not going anywhere.

Which made this summer’s “George Karl wants trade Cousins” a battle the coach couldn’t ultimately win — the owner wasn’t going to sign off on it, and the fans are going to side with Boogie. Remember Karl said he never had a player that was untradable, and that spiraled into reports Karl probed trade options with other teams, much to the frustration of management and Cousins himself.

Karl owned up to some of his mistakes in an interview on Comcast Bay Area, as reported by James Ham at

“To be honest with you, I apologized to DeMarcus for making the trade comment that I’ve never coached a player that’s untradeable,” Karl told Christensen. “That was wrong for me to say, because you all (the media) took it and blew it up into crazy.”

“But it’s my responsibility to be smart enough to not say things like that,” Karl continued. “So I did apologize because I thought that was the only thing, maybe some other things, but really the only thing that got us separated was that comment that then everybody wrote the we’re going to trade [Cousins].”

The relationship between Cousins and Karl — not to mention Rajon Rondo and other veterans — is the biggest key to the Kings’ season. Karl and Cousins say their relationship is solid now, but what happens when that is put under stress at some point during the season?

In talking to people around the team, the Kings players seemed to have formed a tight bond — even if part of the glue of that bond is a distrust of Karl that can work for them. This is a team that has the talent to compete for the bottom couple playoff seeds in the Western Conference, but everybody needs to be pulling on the rope in the same direction. We will see pretty quickly if the Kings can do that.

Pistons reveal “Detroit Chrome” alternate uniform

1 Comment

I’m a fan of the Pistons’ alternate uniforms in general — their “Motor City” ones may be may favorite alternates around the league.

Now they have a new one — Detroit Chrome.

The Pistons will break these out for seven home games this season. From the official release:

The inspiration for the Detroit Chrome jerseys came about as a way to honor our coolest cars from the past and the cars of the future. Detroit is universally known as the auto capital of the world, where chrome leaves an indelible mark on the cars we create. The uniforms feature a matte chrome base color with clean simple lines inspired by the classic muscle cars that have roared up and down Woodward Avenue for decades. The navy trim and Detroit emblazoned across the chest represent the blue collar work ethic that the auto industry and region was built on.

Clean, simple, cool — I like it.

That would look good in the first round of the playoffs, too. (I’m predicting they get the eight seed.)